Lindsay Clancy psychologist casts doubts on psychosis claim over ‘very unusual’

faced backlash for asking Patrick’s mother, Sue Clancy, if she was aware that murder is a sin.”},{“caption”:”Lindsay Clancy, who is accused of killing her three young children in 2023, listens to a witness on video during her Plymouth Superior Court trial in Plymouth, Massachusetts, U.S. August 24, 2026. Greg Derr/Pool via REUTERS”,”height”:”616″,”id”:”SqPfRxalxO”,”src”:”https://i.dailymail.com/1s/2026/08/24/19/1787597841742_wide_galleryImage_Lindsay_Clancy_who_is_acc.JPG”,”type”:”image”,”width”:”634″}],”type”:”POST”},{“articleId”:”16075761″,”author”:”rachel bowman”,”breaking”:false,”closing”:false,”exclusive”:false,”goal”:false,”icons”:[],”keyUpdate”:false,”matchTimestamp”:””,”pinned”:false,”showPostTime”:true,”status”:”live”,”tags”:[],”title”:{“text”:”Heilbrun says Clancy’s response to Patrick on day of killings indicates she was not in psychosis”,”url”:””},”user”:””,”creationDate”:”2026-08-24T18:51:31.645Z”,”updateDate”:”2026-08-24T18:51:31.645Z”,”publishDate”:”2026-08-24T18:51:31.645Z”,”id”:”x6cdNaABAbMgX9ogDXW9″,”lines”:[{“id”:”c9SBJjSew9″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”When Patrick came home and found Clancy injured in the yard, he had asked her: ‘What did you do?'”},{“id”:”flv-sJLooB”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”JMlLcQWD7M”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Clancy responded: ‘I tried to kill myself.'”},{“id”:”Jh0RbZR-w1″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”Eou2PjVjuV”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”If she was experiencing a command hallucination, Heilbrun said he would have expected her to say something more like: ‘I did what I had to do’ or ‘I did what the voice said.'”},{“id”:”73pvhnX0Rp”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”_c4KJpX4fY”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Heilbrun also cast doubts on her claim of psychosis due to other reasons, including the recovery of memories from that day.”}],”type”:”POST”},{“articleId”:”16075761″,”author”:”rachel bowman”,”breaking”:false,”closing”:false,”exclusive”:false,”goal”:false,”icons”:[],”keyUpdate”:false,”matchTimestamp”:””,”pinned”:false,”showPostTime”:true,”status”:”live”,”tags”:[],”title”:{“text”:”Heilbrun discusses Clancy’s motivations for killing children”,”url”:””},”user”:””,”creationDate”:”2026-08-24T18:29:08.773Z”,”updateDate”:”2026-08-24T18:29:08.773Z”,”publishDate”:”2026-08-24T18:29:08.773Z”,”id”:”CacINaABAbMgX9ogkFwm”,”lines”:[{“id”:”zGVbhj6aIT”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”The psychiatrist said he wanted to determine Clancy’s motive for killing her children.”},{“id”:”wvWx7lY3Wm”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”Cx_9oW50jv”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”He said it was so ‘out of character for Lindsay Clancy’ that he wanted to find out ‘what had gone on.'”},{“id”:”jgKjYEjaI7″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”O2ImV0fkKX”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”‘It seems so out of character so I thought it was very important to figure out why that happened,’ he said.”},{“id”:”lUW1MJGH9z”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”qpJlnr74h-“,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”He said that this would help determine criminal responsibility.”},{“id”:”dvZYyHg3__”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”a02h91MiR5″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”He came up with two possible explanations for ‘the why.'”},{“id”:”pyHXBIirm7″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”o1bdOB4zj2″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”One was ‘acute psychosis with command hallucinations.'”},{“id”:”FLBOV-gjRX”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”jYzylg8sCr”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”The second possible explanation was a serious suicide attempt where she wanted to take her children with her so they didn’t suffer without her.”},{“id”:”H5RNQPhEQw”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”3gGSiA6sgn”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Heilbrun said he believes most of the evidence supports the second explanation. “}],”type”:”POST”},{“articleId”:”16075761″,”author”:”rachel bowman”,”breaking”:false,”closing”:false,”exclusive”:false,”goal”:false,”icons”:[],”keyUpdate”:false,”matchTimestamp”:””,”pinned”:false,”showPostTime”:true,”status”:”live”,”tags”:[],”title”:{“text”:”Psychiatrist say Clancy’s suicide attempt was ‘very serious'”,”url”:””},”user”:””,”creationDate”:”2026-08-24T18:26:12.402Z”,”updateDate”:”2026-08-24T18:26:12.402Z”,”publishDate”:”2026-08-24T18:26:12.402Z”,”id”:”yJgFNaABic4hluTF32kz”,”lines”:[{“id”:”SruB6RvGUE”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Dr Heilbrun is back on the stand and testifying about his findings after evaluating Clancy this April.”},{“id”:”WJKg57pSRc”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”BsX-WVZvka”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”She showed a slight tendency to underreport and deny her experiences. But she did this in a way that was ‘sophisticated,’ he said. ‘She is a bright woman.'”},{“id”:”JX3GwqdzVO”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”zGIhvr_5oV”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”On the MMPI – a psychological test – he found that she was not symptomatic on any areas other than the suicide and death ideation scale.”},{“id”:”mFylm2TLyW”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”VXKlzTdvQd”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”She has been on one-to-one suicide watch ever since she went to Tewksbury Hospital. That is a very long time, he said – which helped lead him to conclude that she is at serious risk of suicide.”},{“id”:”Y3Oj-0HdJO”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”ySZRh7g6y9″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”When she filled out a suicide scale, her answers showed that January 2023 was a very serious suicide attempt.”},{“id”:”kcpv4cU-0a”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”MkLXxhzHZN”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Her description of how she was doing in January 2023 was that she was very hopeless about the future and had a feeling that something was very, very wrong with her mind, he testified.”},{“id”:”H56hkxVXPX”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”vcsS4sOZ1r”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Several jurors are writing down lots of notes in their notepads.”}],”type”:”POST”},{“articleId”:”16075761″,”author”:”rachel bowman”,”breaking”:false,”closing”:false,”exclusive”:false,”goal”:false,”icons”:[],”keyUpdate”:false,”matchTimestamp”:””,”pinned”:false,”showPostTime”:true,”status”:”live”,”tags”:[],”title”:{“text”:”Court resumes”,”url”:””},”user”:””,”creationDate”:”2026-08-24T18:15:45.954Z”,”updateDate”:”2026-08-24T18:15:45.954Z”,”publishDate”:”2026-08-24T18:15:45.954Z”,”id”:”iKf8NKABAbMgX9ogUEwj”,”lines”:[{“id”:”9tquabocL2″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Court is back in session after the lunch break.”},{“id”:”9EXmNMIhVp”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”9jUKTvyLiP”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Clancy is now wearing a cream sweater.”},{“id”:”PKL4R4kdpA”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”3czUOu1Zks”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”The prosecution has resumed questioning Dr Kirk Heilbrun.”}],”type”:”POST”},{“keyUpdate”:false,”pinned”:false,”updateDate”:”2026-08-24T18:15:00.893Z”,”goal”:false,”matchTimestamp”:””,”author”:”rachel bowman”,”articleId”:”16075761″,”publishDate”:”2026-08-24T18:15:00.893Z”,”icons”:[],”title”:{“text”:”Who is on the Lindsay Clancy jury?”,”url”:””},”creationDate”:”2026-08-24T14:56:37.220Z”,”tags”:[],”closing”:false,”scheduleDate”:”2026-08-24T18:15:00.000Z”,”exclusive”:false,”id”:”AaZFNKABAbMgX9og_Wdk”,”showPostTime”:true,”user”:””,”breaking”:false,”status”:”live”,”lines”:[{“id”:”QVjX7E2DbO”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”After a week long jury selection in July, 12 women and six men were seated to decide the fate of Lindsay Clancy.”},{“id”:”NckJFY0U_Y”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”ZVhYSIhi6O”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”They will not know until the case is sent for deliberation who is an alternate.”},{“id”:”i_ASQbbDgY”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”u5EE3xubT8″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”The judge seated 18 jurors including six alternates – a higher-than-normal number due to the length of the trial, its high-profile nature and the likely grueling testimony.”}],”type”:”POST”},{“keyUpdate”:false,”pinned”:false,”updateDate”:”2026-08-24T18:00:00.922Z”,”goal”:false,”matchTimestamp”:””,”author”:”rachel bowman”,”articleId”:”16075761″,”publishDate”:”2026-08-24T18:00:00.922Z”,”icons”:[],”title”:{“text”:”Lindsay Clancy’s life locked in psych ward”,”url”:””},”creationDate”:”2026-08-24T15:00:24.234Z”,”tags”:[],”closing”:false,”scheduleDate”:”2026-08-24T18:00:00.000Z”,”exclusive”:false,”id”:”UaZJNKABAbMgX9ogdGsr”,”showPostTime”:true,”user”:””,”breaking”:false,”status”:”live”,”lines”:[{“id”:”jT4-JB93zW”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Behind the doors of the pre-Civil War psychiatric facility, the former nurse who once cared for her own patients has become the patient herself.”},{“id”:”S_Ro0ixnHU”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”xIZE7o-iWP”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”There, confined to a wheelchair, she receives round-the-clock care for her physical and mental health, following what her defense says was a severe episode of postpartum psychosis and depression.”},{“content”:{“metadata”:{“image”:”https://i.dailymail.com/1s/2026/08/19/06/110721237-0-image-a-8_1787116508676.jpg”,”socialHeadline”:”Lindsay Clancy’s true feelings about husband Patrick inside psych ward”,”previewText”:”For the past three years, Lindsay Clancy has called Tewksbury Hospital her home. Now, her weekly visitor gives an astonishing glimpse into her life.”},”url”:”https://www.dailymail.com/crime-desk/article-16053859/lindsay-clancy-psych-ward-patrick-trial.html?_gl=1*ti5axd*_gcl_au*OTUwMTI3MDMzLjE3ODM5NDkwNTkuLS4tLjE3ODY3MTA1MDguMTU2MDgzOTczLjE3ODY3MTA1MDkuMTc4NjcxMDUwOA..*_ga*MTI4NDAxNTMzNC4xNzUyODQwNTAy*_ga_C9F47K6NW6*czE3ODcyMjcwMjYkbzEzNzMkZzEkdDE3ODcyMzIyOTQkajM5JGwwJGgxNjAzNDQxODMw”},”id”:”UDmTkDZd94″,”type”:”dailymail”}],”type”:”POST”},{“keyUpdate”:false,”pinned”:false,”updateDate”:”2026-08-24T17:45:00.721Z”,”goal”:false,”matchTimestamp”:””,”author”:”rachel bowman”,”articleId”:”16075761″,”publishDate”:”2026-08-24T17:45:00.721Z”,”icons”:[],”title”:{“text”:”What sentence is Lindsay Clancy facing?”,”url”:””},”creationDate”:”2026-08-24T15:01:35.533Z”,”tags”:[],”closing”:false,”scheduleDate”:”2026-08-24T17:45:00.000Z”,”exclusive”:false,”id”:”oJFKNKABH4mU3q64igut”,”showPostTime”:true,”user”:””,”breaking”:false,”status”:”live”,”lines”:[{“id”:”PdWhzBzzo8″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Lindsay Clancy is on trial for the murders of her three children, Cora, five, Dawson, three, and eight-month-old Callan, at her home in Duxbury in January 2023.”},{“id”:”9qEWg8ljAP”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”2Qk2PKbMZo”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”She does not deny she killed them, but has pleaded not guilty and claimed she is not responsible for her actions because she was suffering postpartum psychosis after being prescribed a powerful cocktail of drugs to cope with depression.”},{“id”:”dKqYxRktYI”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”x8bR0dB8li”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”The prosecution has argued the killings were intentional and well planned, not the work of someone who had lost control.”},{“id”:”5HBRkzLUqC”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”OigWBcH8sy”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”If convicted of murder, she faces life in prison without parole.”},{“id”:”Sh1awnkSwG”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”cVv0wlhmBO”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”If found not guilty due to a lack of criminal responsibility, she would be committed to a state mental health facility.”},{“caption”:”15450549 Lindsay Clancy was overmedicated on 12 prescription drugs that were \”turning her into a zombie\” – and causing her to experience homicidal thoughts that led to her allegedly strangling her three kids, according to her lawyer.\”One of the major issues here is the horrific overmedication of drugs that caused homicidal ideation, suicidal ideation,” attorney Kevin Reddington told the Boston Globe on Friday.”,”height”:”422″,”id”:”L_V2rmMDGH”,”src”:”https://i.dailymail.com/1s/2026/08/24/16/1787583689162_wide_galleryImage_15450549_Lindsay_Clancy_w.JPG”,”type”:”image”,”width”:”634″}],”type”:”POST”},{“keyUpdate”:false,”pinned”:false,”updateDate”:”2026-08-24T17:30:00.609Z”,”goal”:false,”matchTimestamp”:””,”author”:”rachel bowman”,”articleId”:”16075761″,”publishDate”:”2026-08-24T17:30:00.609Z”,”icons”:[],”title”:{“text”:”Lindsay Clancy’s supporters are all suddenly acting strange. I’m afraid of what they might do next: KENNEDY”,”url”:””},”creationDate”:”2026-08-24T14:59:09.941Z”,”tags”:[],”closing”:false,”scheduleDate”:”2026-08-24T17:30:00.000Z”,”exclusive”:false,”id”:”n5FINKABH4mU3q64UQv1″,”showPostTime”:true,”user”:””,”breaking”:false,”status”:”live”,”lines”:[{“id”:”bWnKFunBrT”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Something very sick is going on…”},{“content”:{“metadata”:{“image”:”https://i.dailymail.com/1s/2026/08/23/14/110802989-0-image-a-33_1787491186614.jpg”,”socialHeadline”:”Something sick is going on with Lindsay Clancy supporters: KENNEDY”,”previewText”:”Hundreds of pink clad protesters, some holding children, have rallied for days. In one hair-raising scene, these ladies made the ‘heart symbol’ with their hands, in unison.”},”url”:”https://www.dailymail.com/debate/article-16072485/Lindsay-Clancy-protest-trial-patrick-KENNEDY.html”},”id”:”EmnHZpwQ36″,”type”:”dailymail”}],”type”:”POST”},{“keyUpdate”:false,”pinned”:false,”updateDate”:”2026-08-24T17:15:00.500Z”,”goal”:false,”matchTimestamp”:””,”author”:”rachel bowman”,”articleId”:”16075761″,”publishDate”:”2026-08-24T17:15:00.500Z”,”icons”:[],”title”:{“text”:”Clancy murder trial discusses suicide”,”url”:””},”creationDate”:”2026-08-24T14:57:31.619Z”,”tags”:[],”closing”:false,”scheduleDate”:”2026-08-24T17:15:00.000Z”,”exclusive”:false,”id”:”9IBGNKABZeC9xJZv0dbk”,”showPostTime”:true,”user”:””,”breaking”:false,”status”:”live”,”lines”:[{“id”:”2av_ZFI6sL”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Lindsay Clancy is accused of murdering her three children – Cora, five, Dawson, three, and eight-month-old Callan – in January 2023.”},{“id”:”DpgrAjSsnM”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”JUM_yQB4yu”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”Although the 36-year-old does not deny killing her children, she has pleaded not guilty and claimed she is not responsible for her actions because she was suffering from postpartum psychosis.”},{“id”:”JlIPL1x9UC”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”IWQp-eIk4-“,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”On the day of the killings, Clancy asked her husband, Patrick Clancy, to leave their home to get takeout food and to pick up something at a pharmacy.”},{“id”:”CrNni7xnyD”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”_aKRSDhozN”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”The former nurse strangled the children with exercise bands, then used multiple methods to try to end her own life.”},{“id”:”ELeIqCG2Rj”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”Re9-4Agwx1″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”She was paralyzed after falling from the home’s second-story window and is being held at a state hospital.”},{“id”:”pTMVazjGxK”,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:””},{“id”:”JTCPa5bgU9″,”type”:”paragraph”,”value”:”If you or someone you know needs help, please call or text the confidential 24/7 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline in the US on 988. There is also an online chat available at 988lifeline.org.“}],”type”:”POST”}],”relatedPuff”:”

“,”totalPosts”:36}” data-platform=”mol.web.desktop” data-channel=”truecrimeuk” data-channel-color=”truecrimeuk” data-version=”5.2.1″ data-reactroot=””>